There must be a reason, and there is: identity politics. But please don’t misunderstand me, my argument is not that there are too many people of colour, or too many trans or gay people writing plays. I am all for diversity (despite what seems to be its increasing lack of popularity). It’s fine to encourage writers of all shapes, sizes and colours — if we don’t give them money and encourage them, then they won’t write, because let me tell you, people are caring less and less about theatre every day when we all have these tiny little masturbatory devices we can turn on whenever we are even slightly bored, and be told by said devices, again and again, that we are good people, and that those who disagree with us are demons. No, we need to find writers, of all dimensions, religions, atheisms, obsessions, attitudes, inspirations, demoninations, origins and kinks. But what we must do, in addition, is stop telling them what to write. (To use the trendy terminology these days -- it's kinda 'colonialist' of you to do so!) I remember back when I was running Buddies in Bad Times Theatre — and it was a gay theatre — a very new thing at the time, and a lot of straight people wouldn’t even go, because they assumed it wasn’t for them, and that it would be a little boring because who really wants to watch something for two hours that is even a little bit — ‘rah rah gay’ even with an intermission (we used to have intermissions in those days, please bring them back!). Yes people assumed the work we did at Buddies would be all about how wonderful it was to be gay, and how fabulous gay people are. But the very opposite was true. I got into a lot of trouble because my plays were quite often about how horrible gay people are. This is not because gay people are particularly horrible — but because plays about nice people are boring. Theatre is best when it is (as my friend David Roche used to say) ‘four people being rude in a room.' So when my gay characters turned out to be not only rude and offensive, but actually sometimes mean, vain, selfish or just plain awful, the ‘gay community’ (always assumed to be a monolith, like all minorities) got up in arms, and raised their sensitive, offended noses a little higher in the air then usual, as if they’d smelled a bad smell, and that smell was homophobia. Homophobia, coming from a gay writer? Jesus. I had one actress drag me off into a corner (God bless her, she had been bullied by public opinion) and ask: ‘Why do you hate gay people so much?’ But I didn’t ‘hate gay people,’ I just didn’t want to write another 'coming out' play about how heroic gay people are. So imagine my surprise when theatres everywhere nowadays do plays about how wonderful people of all shapes and colours of sizes are. No, I’m not imagining it. It’s gotten so bad that if a person is let’s say Black, or Asian, or Indigenous they are attacked for not writing about being Black, Asian or Indigenous, and certainly would be blacklisted (like I was - and Mordecai Richler was, back in the day) by their ‘own people’ for not writing in a complimentary fashion about their own kind. Yes, let’s encourage all kinds of writers — as long as they are good writers — but, again, let’s not tell them what to write! Am I the only person who’s dreadfully bored with seeing a play telling me how awful I am for being a prejudiced person, and demanding I embrace someone else's victimhood? Am I the only person who is tired of going to plays to be preached at? Am I the only person who doesn’t want to know who the good guys and the bad guys are at the start of the play, because isn’t the whole point of art and theatre and poetry and movies and novels is that we are all shades of grey? There are certainly really evil people in the world (they are called rapists and murderers) but most people are not either very good or very bad, but a befuddling mix of both. Why can’t theatre reflect that, once again? Why can’t theatre make us fight to understand human nature, and force us look inside and question ourselves, rather than confirming our superficial preconceived notions of who we are, or rather, imagine ourselves to be?
I remember when going to the theatre was a surprise! You never know what the hell they were going to do or say up there…..
Please! I beg of you! Help!
Me, I just wanna stop falling asleep in the front row.